Best Ice Cream Spots in Westchester County

By Lisa Dunleavy, Macaroni Kid Chappaqua & Karen Savir, Macaroni Kid Westchester North July 18, 2019

Loved by kids and adults of all ages, ice cream is the best cold and refreshing summer treat (however, quite honestly I can eat it all year long).  Lisa Dunleavy owner of Macaroni Kid Chappaqua and I Karen Savir of Macaroni Kid Westchester North have sampled many ice cream shops over the years and here are our favorites:

King Kone

109 NY – Route 100, Katonah

Blue Bird Ice Cream

19 N Salem Rd, Cross River

Cold Stone Creamery

80 Route 6, Somers

Aunti B's Yogurt Bar

325 Route 100, Somers


75 S. Greeley Avenue, Chappaqua

Village Creamery & Sweetshop

32 Broadway, Valhalla

Ben & Jerry's

639 East Main Street, Mt. Kisco

Frannie's Goody Shop

134 E. Main Street, Mt. Kisco


59 Marble Avenue, Pleasantville


505 Bedford Road, Pleasantville

The Blue Pig

121 Maple St, Croton-On-Hudson

Croton Creamery

171 S Riverside Ave, Croton-On-Hudson

Penny Lick

580 Warburton Avenue, Hastings-on-Hudson

Main Street Sweets

35 Main St, Tarrytown

Lighthouse Ice Cream Co

127 Main St, Tarrytown

Jimmy's Soft Serve

81 Sheldon Avenue, Tarrytown

Murray's Ice Cream

240 Halstead Avenue, Harrison

The Hudson Creamery

55 Hudson Avenue, Peekskill

Longford's Own-Made Ice Cream

4 Elm Place, Rye